Tamron 150-600 g2 vs sigma 150-600 sport. Reviews comparing Tamron 150 2020-01-02

Tamron SP 150

Focus is smoother, faster, and surer. The results at 600mm are extremely close, but the result at 500mm gives a significant edge to the contemporary version. Its price-to-performance ratio makes it an excellent value. This is definitely more than a minor tweak. While the Sigma variants and have both proven to be a little sharper at 600mm, the Tamron proves sharper at some other focus distances. It will take 5% off your entire order! The bad news is that, unlike its successor, this lens will require a trip to Tamron's service department to modify the firmware should an upgrade be necessary. The consistent damping in the zoom ring will help a lot for those that want to use the lens for shooting video, and I also noted that it helped eliminate zoom creep when the lens is pointed down.

Tamron SP 150

I found that the A011 could sometimes have sticking points in the zoom action where more effort was required. Some of the reviewers I found said they felt the Sport had an very slight edge in sharpness, and others felt, as I did, that the Contemporary was just barely sharper. I'd like to see a couple tear downs to see how well sealed these lenses are, and what the difference is. While both lenses turn in average performances when it comes to flare, the Contemporary version features when the sun is in the corner of the frame. Most notable was the lens hood. The barrel extends smoothly with very consistent damping throughout the zoom range. I am curious to see Part 2 of his evaluation as well.

Sigma 150

You can shoot macro ish shots from over 7 feet away now that is a nice working distance!! Do check it out to find out more. Except for the high-price, we like the lens a lot! The zoom and focus rings both have a nicer feel in both the materials and in their actions. I'm often hiking, pushing through snow in Yellowstone, etc. A lot of thought has been put into the tactile responses, and it shows in the quality action of the switches. The third party manufacturers have solidly filled a niche that the big two lens manufacturers have yet to fill. It did to me too, so I repeated some of my tests 3 and 4 and 5 times to be certain that the results were right. I took multiple photos with each lens at each focal length, and here I'm displaying the photo from each side that best represents the average result that I was getting at each focal length.

Which 150

The lens can be locked in at any focal length very easily and positively. The 150-600 G2 significantly undercuts the weight of the 6. The zoom ring can be moved forward which engages a friction mechanism that holds the lens at whatever zoom position it is at. . One tip for saving a ton of money on these lenses is to buy used. The Sigma version, however, is a good deal more sophisticated — while the Tamron lens only locks at its widest setting of 150mm, the Sigma can lock at several focal settings, and also boasts a nice feature where it can be unlocked with a sharp twist.

≫ Sigma 150

I am looking to get one of these two lenses. If you find that you are disappointed with your sharpness from this lens, that is the first place you need to check. This one is a tough call. And, even image quality is close enough among the group to not be a major decision factor. Like the previous generation the lens is designed in Japan, manufactured in China save the lens hood, which is manufactured in the Philippines , and distributed to me in Canada. Both of these are just twist-to-zoom lenses. Each copy of a lens performs differently, so to see some slight variation is normal.

Tamron SP 150

Dan In terms of build Quality you can't compare both lense. Plus, image stabilization is directly built into the lens which uses advanced algorithm which the company claims to help you get sharper images in challenging scenarios. One obvious advantage of this lens is its budget-friendly price. No single offset in camera worked well for me. However, this difference in the physical length also affects the way the lenses are engineered, and means that the Sport version has a larger front element which requires 105mm filters, while the Contemporary takes 95mm filters. Can the deliver on its spec list promise? The initial reviews of the Tamron look pretty solid, and you can't beat the weight or the price as compared to the Sigma.

Tamron SP 150

However, that's exactly what's happened. If I had to pick a winner in the sharpness battle, it'd be the Sigma 150-600mm Contemporary, which had better contrast at several focal lengths and better resolution at one focal length. It matches or beats the Sigma Sport with a lot less weight. As a result, the lens delivers high resolution, improved sharpness and overall better performance. Filters of this size are certainly not inexpensive, but. When shooting wildlife and sports photography, which would be the primary uses of this lens, having a very stiff zoom ring can easily cause you to miss shots. The low light performance is, well, it's not.

Tamron 150

These superzooms are performing really well. I used it that way almost exclusively save some controlled tests and moon shots. These successive photos at 500mm and then 600mm clearly demonstrate how sharp this lens can be. I believe that Dustin will find the performance of the Tamron G2 very good in practical outdoor photography. But after spending a lot of time with both of these lenses, I found that ease of use was one of my biggest complaints with the Sport version of this lens. Comparing the G2 to the A011 in a variety of situations I could definitely see some improved sharpness and contrast at 600mm, though at the cost of a bit of light transmission undoubtedly the result of that extra element. I'm owing both the Contemporary and the G2.

Which 150

So when it comes right down to it, after hours of testing and reviewing many many many photos, the sharpness is almost identical between the two lenses. Compared side by side the G2 switches all have a much nice, more definite feel. . For field use they all have very little variation. I repeated the sharpness test at every focal length imaginable. Customisation The Sigma lens features an additional custom control switch to toggle customised settings Comparing the controls of the two lenses side by side, you may notice an additional switch on the Sigma model. .

TAMRON 150

My time with the lens has demonstrated that in this my initial impressions were mostly accurate. Both lenses show very slight pincushion over the entire focal length range. Price The price on these lenses seems to be fluctuating a bit now that they have been out for a little while, so it's worth checking. Using a 600mm prime lens is not always feasible due to its weight and haze in certain environments. Because the Sport is so much heavier, it takes a solid twist of the hand to zoom the lens. You may notice mild pincushion distortion if straight lines are near the long edges of your frame.